Algae Business by Riggs Eckelberry Mixed-Cycle Production, the Growth Breakthrough

Algae Business: Mixed-Cycle Production, the Growth Breakthrough

February 29, 2012
AlgaeIndustryMagazine.com

Arecent OriginOil study concluded that algae producers can make gasoline and diesel at their place of production for as little as $2.28/gallon, using a blend of algae and waste feedstocks. ($5.44/gallon using pure algae.) The model assumes a production footprint of at least 50 hectares (124 acres).

We provided further details on our analysis in a company presentation available at this link. (If you’re an algae industry insider, you can see the underlying model itself, in confidence. Just contact us at the Partners desk.)

Important note: the OriginOil End to End Algae Production Model referenced here is a preliminary study and numbers are subject to change. It is a theoretical analysis and final results will depend on proving at scale of a number of still-new technologies.

Source: OriginOil End to End Algae Production Model, 24 Feb 2012

Source: OriginOil End to End Algae Production Model, 24 Feb 2012

* Wholesale price is based on average price of gasoline and diesel (US, 2/20/2012) after cost of crude oil and refining, before marketing, distribution and taxes.

How are these numbers achieved?

Algae production has become a lot more efficient in this model, but the prospective gains are in three specific areas:

  1. Advanced growth techniques. These quite literally make the difference between profitability and loss.
  2. Increased harvesting efficiency. Harvesting, once a huge cost and energy drain, now potentially trails both fuel conversion and growth in both capital and operating expenses.
  3. Distributed fuel conversion into gasoline and diesel. A number of promising players are now on the scene with processes they claim can be deployed at algae production sites. They appear to have dealt with many of the issues we have been faced with on the pyrolysis front.

Of these three, Advanced Growth is the biggest jump.

Source: OriginOil End to End Algae Production Model, 24 Feb 2012

Source: OriginOil End to End Algae Production Model, 24 Feb 2012

What are advanced growth techniques?

There are promising developments from a number of players (including OriginOil) in the area of growth enhancement, but most of the prospective gain in our model comes down to one thing: the adoption of mixotrophic (mixed-cycle) growth.

What is mixotrophic production and why is it so great?

Normally we think of algae being grown either autotrophically (using light as an energy source) or heterotrophically (nutrition obtained by digesting organic compounds). So when we make algae in the sun, we are autotrophic. When we make it “in the dark”, we are heterotrophic. When we do both, we are mixotrophic.

Solar, or dark – or both?

In my previous column Algae—Food or Chemical Grade?, I explored the place that the dark cycle has in algae production, and concluded that it is best suited to making food-grade algae. And, algae made in the sun are more appropriate to making fuels and chemicals.

Now, advanced algae players are pursuing a hybrid solution: growing algae in the sun and then switching it to a boost phase, fed in the dark with organic compounds. If you’re making fuel, the feed on the heterotrophic side needs to be organic waste to make cost-effective sense.

Ken Reynolds, our VP Marketing, reviewed developments in this exciting area. Here’s Ken.

“As some algae producers have recently switched their focus from fuels to food and feed, it raises the question of what will it take to get to truly cost effective and sustainable biofuels derived from algae? Several recent AIM articles touched on the critical challenges and key opportunities for improvement.

Industry researchers discuss the mixed cycle

“Ron Pate of Sandia Labs provided what I think is a pretty accurate assessment of the current state of affairs regarding the use of algae as a feedstock or production platform for biofuels. In particular he discussed the benefits and limits for the two most widely used algae production methods (heterotrophic and autotrophic).

“In another recent AIM article, Dr. Richard Sayre, Director of the Enterprise Rent-A-Car Institute for Renewable Fuels and CTO of Phycal, also pointed out the need for better methods for algae production.

“In summary, while the potential for environmentally sustainable production could be high for autotrophic algae, it needs further improvements to achieve cost-competitive yields. The yields for heterotrophic growth on the other hand can be quite impressive, but there are major issues regarding the use of sugar and a fair amount of uncertainty as to the true timing, availability and pricing of sugars and starches from non-food sources.

“In the article, Dr. Sayre also discussed how mixotrophic production is being planned for Phycal’s planned Hawaii facility by using sewage and cassava as nutrient sources. There is no question that using waste to feed the algae in mixotrophic phase is the sustainable wave of the future.

“In some mixotrophic models, the algae is started as an autotrophic culture and then switched to a dark heterotrophic cycle to ‘fatten’ up. Another model that may prove to be equally or more effective is to grow the algae using a simultaneous feeding of CO2 and organic nutrients, with some level of light – but not necessarily full sunlight.

Productivity exceeding one gram per liter per day

“With mixotrophic production we start to see major cost improvements in the resulting biomass and lipid content. Based on lab and pre-pilot test results achieved by OriginOil partners and algae producers, we think mixotrophic productivity could easily exceed one gram of new biomass per liter of culture per day with very high lipid content.

“Note that while lipid levels can be quite high, we are using overall biomass as the primary point of comparison to account for differences across various downstream uses. Also, productivity is calculated based on culture volume rather than surface area as calculations used for autotrophic solar exposure become less relevant.

“This may seem quite high to those familiar with autotrophic growth and woefully low compared to heterotrophic output, but all productivity is relative to capital and operating costs. The key of course is to achieve the optimum productivity without competing with the food chain in the process. I tend to agree with Dr. Sayre that the mixotrophic approach may well be the most viable and sustainable solution in the long run, especially at the production volumes and price points required for biofuels.”

Thank you, Ken.

To conclude, I see two additional areas that mixotrophy affects deeply: considerations of land area, and how much sun we need.

Maybe we don’t need as much space

Based on figures that Aurora Algae provided in 2011 for its six-acre demonstration plant, large-scale pure photosynthetic growth generates roughly 200 kg of biomass per hectare per day. That appears to convert to about three-quarters of a barrel of fuel equivalent per day. Perhaps the science can do more, but will we get multiples of that? Perhaps, but then the costs start to escalate dramatically.

The affordable multiples we need may come from the mixed cycle, greatly reducing the acreage needed for viable fuel production.

We can make algae in the higher latitudes

The conventional wisdom for algae is that it only works in high-sun areas. This makes people in Sweden and Canada wonder how they are going to make algae industrially — meaning, year-round.

One answer might be, again, to mix the cycles, in varying ratios, according to the seasons.

Clearly, there’s lots of work ahead to make mixed-cycle production work for our industry, but the evidence in our model seems to indicate that mixotrophic production will be essential to algae production going forward.

Go to HOME Page

Copyright ©2010-2012 AlgaeIndustryMagazine.com. All rights reserved. Permission granted to reprint this article in its entirety. Must include copyright statement and live hyperlinks. Contact editorial@algaeindustrymagazine.com. A.I.M. accepts unsolicited manuscripts for consideration, and takes no responsibility for the validity of claims made in submitted editorial.

Visit the A.I.M. Archives

AIM interview ArchivesAlgae 101 ArchivesHot Products ArchivesInnovations ArchivesMoney ArchivesProcess ArchivesResearch ArchivesScale Up ArchivesThe Buzz Archives

FREE Algae News & Updates

Sign up to receive breaking A.I.M. updates!

From The A.I.M. Archives

— Refresh Page for More Choices
The Algae Biomass Organization (ABO) released the following statement calling on the EPA to include Carbon Capture and Utilization strategies in rules proposed June 2, 20...
A new, outdoor system at the University of Dayton Research Institute has been producing a high volume of algae since its installation in the summer of 2013, even through ...
Four years after the first optimistic calculations, the experimental cultivation of algae at Wageningen University in the Netherlands appears to be meeting expectations. ...
A University of New South Wales (UNSW)-led team of researchers has discovered how algae that survive in very low levels of light are able to switch on and off a weird qua...
Algae Industry Magazine is pleased to announce a new Algae 101 series by our popular blogger, Mark Edwards, Professor, Arizona State University. The Algae Solutions to Na...
Starting in the early 70s, agencies in the former USSR invested more than 20,000 person-years of research and development to produce Bio-Algae Concentrates (BAC) that hel...
In an effort to propel the algae industry forward, the Algae Testbed Public Private Partnership (ATP3) offers a series of hands-on specialized workshops suited for partic...
Following a request from the European Commission, the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) Panel on Dietetic Products, Nutrition and Allergies (NDA) was recently asked t...
Phys.Org reports that scientists Jolanda Verspagen and Jef Huisman of the University of Amsterdam, The Netherlands have concluded that rising CO2 concentrations in the at...
Expanding from its initial work in algal biofuels, General Atomic’s (GA’s) Advanced Biological Processes team has focused on the rising need for food globally, specifical...
Oregon State University researchers are combining diatoms, a type of single-celled photosynthetic algae, with nanoparticles to create a sensor capable of detecting minisc...
Researchers at the Paul Scherer Institute (PSI) in Wädenswil, Switzerland, have succeeded in producing energy-rich gas from microalgae, and in doing so have demonstrated ...
SCHOTT AG, of Mitterteich, Germany, and Algatechnologies Ltd. (Algatech), based at Israel’s Kibbutz Ketura, have signed an R&D agreement to strengthen their partnersh...
Biplab Das reports in NatureAsia.com that a research team has found aqueous extracts of the marine brown algae Lobophoro variegate that can inhibit the replication of hum...
James “Jamie” Levine took over the reigns at Sapphire Energy in July of this year as former President and CEO Cynthia “CJ” Warner stepped down, retaining her role as chai...
Algix, parent company of Solaplast, will be inaugurating their algae-to-plastic facility in Meridian, Mississippi, on November 14, 2014. Solaplast's facility will be focu...
Hortidaily.com reports that in Nevele, Belgium, Tomalgae is growing algae in a former tomato greenhouse. Their company was formed when tomato cultivation entrepreneurs Pi...
On September 25, 2014, a photobioreactor for the cultivation of algae was officially unveiled during a seminar at Thomas More University College in Mechelen, Belgium. Und...