Algae Business by Riggs Eckelberry The Economics of Power Plant CO2 Capture

The Economics of Power Plant CO2 Capture

July 4, 2011
AlgaeIndustryMagazine.com

In assessing strategies, some power plants will find algae the best long-range option.In April, I wrote that CO2 capture is algae’s “killer app”—the deployment that addresses four environmental problems at once. Now the killer app can look forward to its first large-scale customers. It’s a killer app because algae feed on CO2, the biggest contributor to greenhouse gas emissions. Algae’s CO2 appetite is prodigious. It takes two parts CO2 to produce one part algae and one part oxygen, making algae a cheap, scalable emission reduction strategy.

Algae facilities can feasibly be located near electrical power plants, the largest single source of CO2 emissions. Today’s carbon capture process requires separating and condensing CO2, then transporting it in dedicated pipelines to distant locations where it can be stored. Processing CO2 close to power plants eliminates the capital and operating costs for transportation. It also eliminates the increasing opposition from localities opposed to pipelines.

Once transported, the gas is usually stored deep in rock formations in a process technically known as sequestration. Sequestration risks are not yet fully known, but its potential liability is ominous. The risk became catastrophically evident in the 1986 disaster in Lake Nyros, Cameroon, when escaped volcanic CO2 settled in a nearby valley and lethally poisoned one thousand seven hundred village residents.

Power plants  will have powerful incentives to consider long-range strategic partnerships to bring algae to scale.The alternative of burying CO2 in ocean water at least one thousand meters deep brings environmental costs that are better known. CO2 is heavier than water, and sinks to ocean bottoms. It kills marine life underneath it, and acidifies water, threatening habitation for many marine species.

By contrast, transforming algae into oil generates clean fuel and other bio-friendly products, substituting for petro fuels that contribute even more greenhouse gases and general air pollution. As environmental bonuses, even the CO2 generated in algae growth and oil extraction can be recycled back into the algae, and the water used can help treat wastewater.

Now, the algae’s killer app may have its first big customers. Emissions standards, with prescribed limits for CO2 emissions, are due to come on line in 2012. The centerpiece of most emissions controls is a market-based exchange system that sets CO2 “allowances”—the amounts of greenhouse gases power plants are permitted to emit. Companies that operate below their allowances can offer surplus allowances for sale. Companies that operate above their allowances can buy allowances at rates set by supply and demand on market exchanges. Companies that exceed their allowances, and fail to purchase sufficient allowances from others, are subject to penalties costly enough to make the allowance exchange market an industry mandate.

Now electric companies will have to look at their bottom lines in a whole new way.  Instead of comparing the control of greenhouse gas emissions with no controls, they have to compare the costs of various strategies to reduce emissions. In assessing strategies, some power plants will find algae the best long-range option.

Power plants located distant from sequestration locations will have to take into account the costs of constructing CO2 transportation pipelines. Compared to such costs, becoming partners with companies that use the gas to feed algae may be a more cost-effective capital investment.

Power plants at the extremes of efficiency may find algae their best option. Inefficient plants that emit especially high levels of greenhouse gases may face penalties so dire that they are forced to choose between major reconstruction, and finding a comprehensive solution for emissions. To stay within their allowances, they may be forced to depend on a process that eliminates, rather than sends and stores, CO2.

Newer, more efficient plants may see an opportunity to earn significant revenue not only from selling electricity, but also from selling emissions cap allowances. The allowance market may float high enough to make allowances a significant revenue source.

Emissions  standards, with prescribed limits for CO2 emissions, are due to come on line in 2012.How penalties are assessed will play a major role in cap-and-trade market prices. If regulators award extra allowances for transforming, as opposed to moving and storing, CO2, then algae will increase its appeal in allowance market cost trade-offs. If regulators impose additional penalties for insecure sequestration, the search for alternatives will become more valuable.

These considerations are now imminent. In January 2012, California’s precedent-setting 2006 cap-and-trade emissions control law, is scheduled to take effect. California’s ambitious goal is reducing greenhouse emissions to 1990 levels no later than 2020. Northeast and Mid-Atlantic states have established a similar plan, and British Columbia and Ontario also come on line in 2012. Thirty-six states now have climate action plans, many of which will likely add cap-and-trade as emissions control strategies.

Cap-and-trade remains controversial, but environmental rationales are now bolstered by economic stability and national security concerns. Most cap-and-trade programs are expected to start and expand by trial-and-error in coming years.

The bottom line for algae is that power plants will have powerful incentives to consider long-range strategic partnerships to bring algae to scale. Complemented by the income from products, algae may offer not only the best, but also the cheapest alternative for some plants in the immediate future. Strategic partnerships could open the door for algae growth and processing of unprecedented size, over long enough time to identify and address issues of large-scale production.

Somewhere in the mix of California, Northeast, and Mid-Atlantic electrical power plants, there are likely to be one, or a few, whose costs of pipeline construction, distance to feasible sequestration locations, shortage of construction capital, or infeasibility of penalties will trigger a need for comprehensive long-term solutions to their CO2 challenge. Other power plants may discover in the new cap-and-trade market a major source of revenue.

For these visionary electric power plants, partnerships with algae firms may prove sufficiently advantageous, even necessary, to warrant the kind of long-term capital investment and large-scale production that demonstrates algae’s unique contribution to address, simultaneously, CO2 emissions and the production of green fuel.

Go to HOME Page

Copyright ©2010-2011 AlgaeIndustryMagazine.com. All rights reserved. Permission granted to reprint this article in its entirety. Must include copyright statement and live hyperlinks. Contact editorial@algaeindustrymagazine.com. A.I.M. accepts unsolicited manuscripts for consideration, and takes no responsibility for the validity of claims made in submitted editorial.

Visit the A.I.M. Archives

AIM interview ArchivesAlgae 101 ArchivesHot Products ArchivesInnovations ArchivesMoney ArchivesProcess ArchivesResearch ArchivesScale Up ArchivesThe Buzz Archives

FREE Algae News & Updates

Sign up to receive breaking A.I.M. updates!

From The A.I.M. Archives

— Refresh Page for More Choices
Tess Riley writes in TheGuardian.com about how spirulina may be able to combat malnutrition in developing countries. Spirulina is one of the oldest life forms on Earth, c...
In an age where customer input is as easy as a click, OriginOil has tapped directly into its intended market to R&D their next generation algae harvester -- with a de...
Fort Myers, FL-based Algenol, and India's Reliance Industries Ltd., have deployed India’s first Algenol algae production platform. The demonstration module is located nea...
Researchers Greg O’Neil of Western Washington University and Chris Reddy of Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution (WHOI), have exploited an unusual and untapped class of c...
In a recent study, published in PLOS ONE Journal, the influence of light intensity on the growth and lipid productivity of Nannochloropsis salina was investigated in a fl...
Kailua Kona, Hawaii-based Cyanotech has announced financial results for the third quarter and first nine months of fiscal year 2015, ended December 31, 2014. For the thir...
Using a malaria parasite protein produced from algae, paired with an immune-boosting cocktail suitable for use in humans, researchers at UC San Diego School of Medicine g...
Solazyme has announced that total revenue for the fourth quarter of 2014 was $14.5 million, compared with $11.3 million in the fourth quarter of 2013, an increase of 29%....
James Goodman writes in the democratandchronicle.com about Jeffrey Lodge, an associate professor of biological sciences at Rochester Institute of Technology, who knows wh...
As one of the most water-poor countries in the world, Jordan’s current water resources are significantly below the global water scarcity line. Annual rainfall falls under...
The European (FP7) algae project Sustainable PoLymers from Algae Sugars and Hydrocarbons (SPLASH) has been developing a platform technology for the conversion of third ge...
In one of the first studies to examine the potential for using municipal wastewater as a feedstock for algae-based biofuels, Rice University scientists found they could e...
Jeff Gelski writes in foodbusinessnews.net that algae oil is now in the toolbox of alternative oils shown to replace partially hydrogenated oils (PHOs), which cause trans...
Algae.Tec has announced a collaboration agreement for the commercialization of its algae production technology with Larimar Energy SRL, of the Dominican Republic. The ene...
Scientific representatives from the EnAlgae consortium are announcing preliminary results this week from a key algal carbon capture project in the works at Britain’s larg...