Algae Business by Riggs Eckelberry Small Scale Algae: An Alternate Vision

Small Scale Algae—An Alternate Vision

June 7, 2011

Most algae production is industrial in scale. Take MBD Energy’s carbon capture project, designed to attack the vast CO2 emissions of Australia’s brown coal power plants. Each power plant emits ten million tons of CO2 per year. At two tons of CO2 to produce one ton of algae, that’s five million tons of algae per year, per plant. That also means billions of cubic meters of water. (Thankfully, algae grow well in brackish or wastewater.)

That’s Big Algae.

Refining Requires Scale

Algae service providers,” along with Small Algae producers, will one day become our own version of The Cloud.Strategic algae buyers are looking for volume. Newly-public Solazyme is committed to delivering a half-million gallons of renewable fuels this year to the US Department of Defense, a huge production increase for our industry. Refining that much algae oil requires industrial scale. Standard oil refineries require 10,000 barrels a day to operate.

While capital is rightly pouring into gigantic projects that we need to begin to compete with oil and gas, there is a parallel business model that takes advantage of algae’s unique ability to be grown in small settings, tapping local sources of nutrients and labor. Let’s call this Small Algae.

Small Algae is Like Distributed Computing

If large-scale industrial algae production is like centralized mainframe processing, Small Algae is like personal computing. And today we know that both are needed. Back in the eighties we actually wondered if mainframes were going to become completely obsolete. Instead, a remarkable synergy has emerged that we call The Cloud, powered by vast arrays of servers and mainframe computing power that serve highly distributed user networks. One literally can’t function without the other. Is it possible that algae could develop in this direction?

To answer that, let’s look at some Small Algae scenarios, our own versions of these “highly distributed user networks”.

Rural Small Algae Production

Imagine an Indian village, with a small water treatment plant, where algae help purify organic waste, digesting it into methane and CO2. The methane is valuable for cooking and transportation, while the CO2 recycles to feed the algae. The whole setup requires skilled, semi-skilled and unskilled labor for water treatment, energy generation and algae production.

An industrialized setting with the same amount of labor could handle a thousand times more volume. But in the village, labor is plentiful and cheap. Small Algae generates jobs and addresses village needs Big Algae can’t reach, including alternatives to expensive petroleum.   And it creates rural jobs, a governmental priority to reduce urban migration.

Exporting Algae for Valuable Products

At the outset, Algae output can be bio-digested for fuel and fertilizer. But as production increases, the excess can be exported as a standardized algae “oily paste” to central locations to make higher-value products. Commodities all over the world use this kind of collection network. As a young second-in-command of an island freighter in the seventies, I helped collect smoke-dried coconut meat “copra” from small places in the southwestern Pacific, shipping them to a central processing plant to make copra cake for cattle, and coconut oil for cosmetics.

That kind of algae collection network can evolve. “Algae service providers”, along with Small Algae producers, will one day become our own version of The Cloud, delivering algae paste from small waste-to-algae centers throughout rural India, to strategically located processing centers.

There is a parallel business model that takes advantage of algae’s unique ability to be  grown in small settings, tapping local sources of nutrients and labor.

Urban Small Algae Production

Back at home, automation is driving ever-higher productivity at the expense of urban semi-skilled and unskilled jobs. Today’s solar and wind renewable energies do little for domestic job creation. Components are manufactured outside the United States, and operating systems require very little labor, most of it skilled.

So how would Small Algae work in a place like Compton, California, where solar and wind alternatives generate neither jobs nor utility rate savings? This isn’t rural India. We already have industrial-scale wastewater treatment facilities, and rural Indian micro-wages have little appeal.

Getting Paid for Reducing Pollution

The key, again, is waste. Local industry puts out waste products that need purifying. Small Algae operations could get paid for capturing CO2 emissions. As greenhouse gas emissions regulation takes shape, electric power plants will increase budgets to comply. Wastewater treatment plants are also looking for cost-effective alternatives. Ideally, Small Algae operations could get paid for absorbing industrial CO2, helping treat wastewater, or both. It would require consistent, effective emissions regulation, which is scheduled to emerge over the next few years.

Absorbing Smog-Creating Chemicals

Los Angeles already has emissions regulations, in place for decades. Here and in some other cities, we regulate smog-producing chemicals such as sulfur dioxide (SO2) and nitrogen oxides (NOx). Algae have a very high value in absorbing these toxins as well. So, in the right place, an urban Small Algae site can acquire the nutrients it needs at no cost, or earn income for removing pollutants like CO2, SO2 or NOx, possibly in conjunction with wastewater treatment.

As in India, urban Small Algae sites must operate inexpensively. In an urban environment, the value of land is an issue, and new technologies for dense algae production are needed.  But above all, the site must be low tech and use inexpensive materials. Just as in India, we would start with simple output options for the algae. But sooner rather than later, we would want to export the algae paste to be “valorized” by an algae service provider.

Local industry puts out waste products that need purifying. Small Algae operations could get paid for capturing CO2 emissions.Finding Support for Urban Algae Production

There are many related issues, such as training the skilled and semi-skilled labor. The algae industry must support the development of vocational training… “Algae U”. Fortunately, organizations like Lift Up America, which OriginOil sponsors, are devoted to developing jobs for inner city youth. They can help raise funds, and lobby for support.

We need Small Algae in parallel with Big Algae, because there is synergy, and because a few massive algae sites won’t be adequate to rapidly improve our energy security and the health of our populations. Like distributed computing, distributed algae production will become a powerful trend in years to come. Small Algae will be very big indeed.

Go to HOME Page

Copyright ©2010-2011 All rights reserved. Permission granted to reprint this article in its entirety. Must include copyright statement and live hyperlinks. Contact A.I.M. accepts unsolicited manuscripts for consideration, and takes no responsibility for the validity of claims made in submitted editorial.

Visit the A.I.M. Archives

AIM interview ArchivesAlgae 101 ArchivesHot Products ArchivesInnovations ArchivesMoney ArchivesProcess ArchivesResearch ArchivesScale Up ArchivesThe Buzz Archives

FREE Algae News & Updates

Sign up to receive breaking A.I.M. updates!



From The A.I.M. Archives

— Refresh Page for More Choices
Kevin Quon writes in Seeking Alpha about the financial plights and pivots of Solazyme, the algae industry’s most high profile recent IPO. In a year that started with a sh...
Fort Myers, FL-based Algenol has announced that the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has approved fuels made from Algenol’s process as an advanced biofuel, meet... is showcasing the “Spirulina Fountain” designed by bureau A. The installation constitutes a hybrid, fusing the production basins of the intense blue-green ...
Developing renewable fuel from wet algae is one of the latest innovations Richland, Washington-based Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) has successfully driven ...
Kailua Kona, Hawaii-based Cyanotech has announced financial results for the third quarter and first nine months of fiscal year 2015, ended December 31, 2014. For the thir... this month gives a well-rounded survey of how algae’s uses in food, beverage, and supplements keep expanding. Here is an excerpt: Thanks to the 201...
Using a malaria parasite protein produced from algae, paired with an immune-boosting cocktail suitable for use in humans, researchers at UC San Diego School of Medicine g...
James Goodman writes in the about Jeffrey Lodge, an associate professor of biological sciences at Rochester Institute of Technology, who knows wh...
Cellana, Inc., with operations in San Diego and Kailua-Kona, Hawaii, has announced that David Anton, Ph.D., has been appointed Chief Operating Officer and elected to the ...
Brian Krassenstein, writing in, goes deeper into the recent paper in Engineering in Life Sciences journal discussing the impact 3D bioprinting will have in th...
Sebastian Rich reports on PBS Newshour about the Central African Republic city of Bangui, which has been caught in the crossfire between warring Muslim and Christian grou...
In one of the first studies to examine the potential for using municipal wastewater as a feedstock for algae-based biofuels, Rice University scientists found they could e...
Simris Alg, a pioneering agribusiness producing omega-3 from farmed algae, has been declared one of Sweden’s 33 hottest companies in new technology. The renowned list is ...
Scientists from the J. Craig Venter Institute (JCVI), a not-for-profit genomic research organization in La Jolla, California, have published a paper outlining new synthet...
Scientific representatives from the EnAlgae consortium are announcing preliminary results this week from a key algal carbon capture project in the works at Britain’s larg...